Gold & Silver
Gold Investment Advice: Where to Get It, and How to Tell Advice From a Sales Pitch
By Thomas Lovas Lokoy — researched and drafted with AI from published sources; edited and published by NorwegianSpark SA (editorial policy) | Last updated: November 2026

The short answer
If you want advice on whether to own gold, how much and in what form, go to a regulated financial adviser whose registration you can check in an official register, and know how they are paid. A precious metals dealer's free consultation is a different thing: it is a sales conversation with a firm that profits from what you buy.
That distinction has legal weight. The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission and FINRA say in a joint investor bulletin that retail metal dealers are not regulated at the federal level. In the UK, the Royal Mint states that investments in physical bullion products are not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, so the Financial Ombudsman and the Financial Services Compensation Scheme do not apply.
For market information without a pitch, use primary sources that sell you nothing directly: the LBMA's published gold prices, issuer documents for any gold fund, and research you read knowing who funds it.
| Where the guidance comes from | What it is | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Regulated financial adviser | A personal recommendation, given under a regulator's rules | Registration in the official register; how they are paid; whether they advise on physical metal, funds or both |
| Bullion dealer consultation | A sales conversation about the dealer's products | All prices, fees and the buy-back price in writing; whether the salesperson is registered if they recommend what to buy |
| Fund issuer documents | Facts about one product: fees, custody, structure | Read the prospectus or annual report, not the marketing page alone |
| Industry research | Data and analysis on the gold market | Who funds it, and the difference between data and opinion |
Why a dealer's consultation is not advice
A dealer earns its money on the difference between what it sells metal for and what it pays, plus any fees. That is a legitimate business, and a good dealer will answer questions about its products honestly. But the person on the phone is paid to sell, and the advice you need, which is whether gold suits you at all and how much of it, is advice a seller cannot give without a conflict.
The CFTC and FINRA bulletin is blunt about the bad end of the market. It says that in most cases the salesperson trying to convince someone to roll over retirement savings into metals has no professional experience and is not qualified to give trading, investment or tax advice, and describes boiler-room telemarketers who may offer a free gift or a limited-time offer, then hand the caller to a 'lead trader'. It adds the line that matters most: if someone tries to persuade you to buy, suggests what to buy, how much or when, that is advice, and they might be required to register with the CFTC, the SEC, FINRA or your state regulator.
In the UK, the Royal Mint's own product pages state that investments in physical bullion products are not regulated by the FCA, so the Financial Ombudsman and FSCS protections are not applicable. If something goes wrong with a bullion purchase, those routes are closed. Advice from an FCA-authorised adviser is regulated, which is why it is worth paying for if you need it.
None of this makes dealers untrustworthy as a class. It means a dealer is the right place to buy, once you have decided what to buy, and the wrong place to decide. Our guide to checking a gold dealer before you buy covers how to pick a good one.
How to check who you are talking to
Registration is public, and checking takes minutes. Use the exact firm name and reference number you are given, not a similar-sounding one, and be wary of anyone who discourages you from checking.
- United States, investment advisers: the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site.
- United States, brokers: FINRA BrokerCheck.
- United States, firms and people registered with the CFTC: the National Futures Association's BASIC database.
- United States, state level: your state securities regulator, and your state attorney general for complaints about a dealer.
- United Kingdom: the FCA's Financial Services Register.
- Elsewhere: your national financial regulator keeps the equivalent register.
Registration and disciplinary history are what you are looking for. The CFTC and FINRA advise asking the salesperson directly whether they are registered, then verifying it and reading the disciplinary history. A regulated adviser will also tell you, in writing, how they are paid: a fee, a percentage of assets, or commission. Knowing that tells you where their incentives lie.
The questions regulators say to ask before you buy
The CFTC and FINRA bulletin is written for American buyers of physical metals, but its questions work anywhere. In short:
- Did they contact you first? The bulletin says never to respond to cold calls, unsolicited emails, junk mail, late-night commercials, infomercials, social media posts or pop-up dealers.
- Is the dealer established? Retail metal dealers are not regulated at the federal level in the US, so check complaint histories with consumer organisations, the state attorney general or the securities regulator, and verify a physical address and how long the dealer has operated.
- Is the salesperson registered? If they tell you what, how much or when to buy, that is advice.
- Is this a gold IRA pitch? Money in a self-directed IRA has no fiduciary guarding against bad investments, and the bulletin reports victims who lost one-third to one-half of their savings to markups, fees and commissions.
- What is the spot price? It should be easy to find; compare the weight you are buying against it.
- What is the spread? The bulletin says some fraudulent dealers have charged spreads of more than 300%, while other dealers charge less than 20%.
- What are all the fees? Ask for every fee, cost, commission and the agreed price in writing before signing or paying. If they are not available in writing, the bulletin calls that a red flag.
- What will it cost to hold? Storage, insurance and administration, and possible tax and penalties if retirement money is involved.
- Is it bullion or a 'semi-numismatic' coin? The bulletin calls semi-numismatic a made-up industry term with no special meaning, often used to justify inflated prices.
- Is there another way to own it? Funds and other regulated products carry their own fees but are regulated; our comparison of gold ETFs and physical gold sets them side by side.
To see what a normal premium over spot looks like, our explainer on what you actually pay over spot breaks it down.
Where to get gold market information without a sales pitch
You do not need a consultation to follow the gold market. The underlying information is published, and most of it is free.
- The price itself. The LBMA Gold Price is set twice daily in auctions run by ICE Benchmark Administration, starting at 10:30 and 15:00 London time, and is the global benchmark for unallocated gold delivered in London. Our explainer on how the gold price is set covers what it is and is not.
- Fund documents. Any gold fund publishes a prospectus and annual reports with its fees, custodian and structure; read those rather than the marketing page.
- Industry research. The World Gold Council publishes widely used demand data and research. Read it knowing who funds it: the World Gold Council says its 29 members are gold mining companies, and it describes itself as a membership organisation that champions gold's role as a strategic asset. Its data is useful; its conclusions come from an organisation whose members sell gold.
- Central bank data. Official reserve figures are published by the central banks themselves; our piece on why central banks buy gold explains what that buying does and does not tell a private buyer.
Forecasts are opinions, whoever publishes them. Treat a bank's or a dealer's price target as one view, not as information about what will happen.
What good advice on gold should cover
Whether it comes from an adviser or from your own reading, a sound decision about gold answers five questions:
- Does gold fit your plan at all? It pays no income and its price can fall sharply.
- How much? A share of your savings you can hold through a long fall without being forced to sell.
- In what form? Coins and bars you hold, vaulted metal, or a fund. Each has different costs, from dealer premiums to annual fees.
- In what tax wrapper? Tax treatment differs by country and by product, and can matter more than the costs.
- How will you sell? Know before you buy who will buy it back and at what spread.
Our guide to gold investment in 2026 works through each of those. If you decide to buy physical metal, compare the same coin or bar across dealers on the same day; Silver Gold Bull's gold coin prices are one reference point (NordicGilt may earn a commission). Nothing here is financial advice.
Gold and collectibles carry risk and prices fluctuate — nothing here is financial advice. Consider your own situation or speak to a qualified adviser.
Related Collections
Sources
Founder & Editor, NorwegianSpark SA
Thomas Lovas Lokoy is the founder of NorwegianSpark SA, the Norwegian company (org. 834 984 172) that runs NordicGilt. He oversees the business. Articles are researched and drafted with AI assistance; Thomas is responsible for what goes live. Corrections: thomaslien@norwegianspark.com.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I get advice on investing in gold?
From a regulated financial adviser whose registration you can check in an official register, such as the FCA Financial Services Register in the UK or the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site in the US. Ask how they are paid and whether they can advise on physical metal, funds or both. A precious metals dealer can tell you about its products, but its consultation is a sales conversation.
Is a gold dealer's free consultation real investment advice?
Treat it as a sales conversation. The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission and FINRA warn that precious metals salespeople are often not qualified to give trading, investment or tax advice, and that someone who suggests what to buy, how much or when may need to be registered. Ask whether they are registered, then check it yourself.
Is buying physical gold regulated by the FCA?
The Royal Mint states that investments in physical bullion products are not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, so the protections of the Financial Ombudsman and the Financial Services Compensation Scheme do not apply. Advice from an FCA-authorised firm is regulated, which is one reason to take advice from one.
How do I check whether a gold salesperson or adviser is registered?
In the US, use the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site for investment advisers, FINRA BrokerCheck for brokers, NFA BASIC for firms and people registered with the CFTC, and your state securities regulator. In the UK, use the FCA Financial Services Register. Elsewhere, your national financial regulator keeps the equivalent register. Check the exact firm name and reference number, not a similar-sounding one.
What spread should I expect when buying gold?
It depends on the product and the dealer, so compare like with like on the same day. The CFTC and FINRA note that some fraudulent dealers have charged spreads of more than 300%, while other dealers charge less than 20%, and they advise asking for every fee and the buy-back price in writing before you pay.
Should I move my retirement savings into a gold IRA?
Be cautious with anyone who suggests it unprompted. The CFTC and FINRA say gold or silver IRA frauds frequently target older workers and retirees, that once money is in a self-directed IRA there are no fiduciaries guarding against bad investments, and that in some cases victims lost one-third to one-half of their savings to markups, fees and commissions. Talk to a tax professional or a registered adviser first.
Continue Reading
gold silver
Silver vs Gold: Which Precious Metal Should You Invest In?
Silver vs gold investment comparison covering returns, volatility, premiums and storage to help you pick the right metal.
gold silver
Best Gold ETFs vs Physical Gold: Pros, Cons and Costs
Gold ETFs vs physical gold comparison for 2026 with fees, liquidity, risks and recommendations for every investor profile.
gold silver
How to Buy Gold Bullion in 2026: Complete Beginner's Guide
Gold bullion buying guide for 2026 covering bars, coins, dealers, storage and costs so you invest with confidence.



